Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Week 6: Top 25 -- TFG

In our top 25 this week a national title contender takes a step backwards, several new legitimate contenders step forward for the second title spot, and a former powerhouse is headed off a cliff.

Rank +/- Team WinPct SoS Off Pts Def Pts Pace
001-- Alabama 0.9497 0.6204 29.1 8.2 78.8
002+2 TCU 0.9275 0.4614 26.1 8.9 82.7
003+2 Boise St. 0.9118 0.4247 28.4 10.6 83.1
004+4 Iowa 0.9072 0.5807 23.6 8.9 81.6
005-2 Ohio St. 0.9027 0.4596 25.7 10.0 81.6
006-4 Florida 0.9008 0.6256 29.3 11.6 78.2
007-- Oregon 0.8866 0.6129 26.1 11.0 92.3
008-2 Virginia Tech 0.8643 0.6046 27.4 12.5 79.3
009+2 Oklahoma 0.8499 0.6579 22.3 10.7 91.6
010+2 Nebraska 0.8480 0.4469 22.9 11.1 81.2
011-1 LSU 0.8435 0.5917 22.4 11.0 79.3
012+1 Texas 0.8117 0.5462 24.4 13.3 82.9
013+2 Arizona 0.8096 0.6474 22.2 12.1 82.5
014-5 Penn State 0.7964 0.6278 17.4 9.8 79.8
015+1 Utah 0.7947 0.3609 23.7 13.5 82.5
016-2 Stanford 0.7944 0.6243 28.2 15.9 82.0
017-- Miami-FL 0.7897 0.6708 22.6 12.9 84.3
018-- Arkansas 0.7616 0.6358 24.9 15.2 82.8
019+4 Auburn 0.7593 0.5301 22.8 14.1 85.7
020-1 USC 0.7217 0.5039 21.1 14.2 83.8
021+1 California 0.7138 0.6359 21.1 14.3 84.0
022-1 Clemson 0.7054 0.5743 20.4 14.0 83.3
023+2 Florida St. 0.6996 0.5954 23.3 16.4 81.3
024-- Air Force 0.6974 0.4968 19.2 13.5 82.2
025NA Oklahoma St. 0.6925 0.5098 23.5 16.7 86.7

New entries: Oklahoma State.

Dropped out: Texas Tech.

Alabama solidifies its hold on the top spot, while TCU, Boise, and Iowa all leapfrog past Ohio State and Florida. Of those three, though, Iowa is struggling to separate themselves from Ohio State and Florida. Their weak offense is the only thing holding them back (conversely, their tied-for-second-best defense is the only thing keeping them up there). Looking at the expected win percent column, we see some stratifications forming. Alabama is ahead, with TCU their closest competition. Boise, Iowa, Ohio State,  and Florida are all bunched together, with Oregon and Virginia Tech in their respective no-man's-land, and Oklahoma, Nebraska, and LSU effectively deadlocked.

Looking down the chart a little ways, we see Arkansas, Auburn, USC and Cal sandwiched between the 0.800 and 0.700 plateaus. USC is struggling under the post-Reggie-Bush sanctions and is ineligible for a bowl game; they are, however, still playing for pride, but that doesn't seem to be getting them much of anywhere these days. They look to be underdogs against at least three other Pac-10 teams, and will be a coin toss against a motivated Cal squad.

The one team that really stands out here, though, is Penn State. The Nittany Lions are in the top 15 solely because of their defense. I know this isn't news to anyone who follows college football, but the degree to which they depend on their defense is staggering. They are one of four teams in I-A with a sub-10.0 PPH defensive efficiency, yet have the worse offensive efficiency in the top 40. They combine a bad offensive outing for Tennessee with an amazing defensive stance by Oklahoma. They went to Alabama and held the Crimson Tide to a mere 24 points, a touchdown less than the Tide hung on Florida. They then went to Iowa and again surrendered only 24 points. In each case, though, State's offense only managed a field goal. If JoePa can start getting UNC-level performance from his offense, the Nittany Lions will be a legitimate top-10 team again.

By this point nearly 45% of the value of these rankings come from the four or five games teams have played in the 2010 season, with the rest coming from 2009 and before. By next week, though, that value will tip past 50% and we'll really get a feel for where teams belong.  Will Texas fall out of the top 25? Will USC fall out of the top 50? Will people continue to not care about the ACC? These answers and more, next week.